Knights+and+Knaves

A very special island is inhabited only by knights and knaves. Knights always tell the truth, and knaves always lie. You meet two inhabitants: Connor and Emily. Connor says that Emily is a knave. Emily says, `I and Connor are knights.' So who is a knight and who is a knave?

**Some questions to try and answer before you begin** (1) Pretend that Connor is a Knave. What does that mean about Connor? What does that imply about Emily? (2) Pretend that Connor is a Knight. What does that mean about Connor? What does that imply about Emily? (3) Pretend that Emily is a Knight. What does that mean about Emily? What does that imply about Connor? (4) Pretend that Emily is a Knave. What does that mean about Emily? What does that imply about Connor?

media type="custom" key="6972699" We thought that Conner was a knight and Emily is a knave because we looked at the possible answers and found that only the statement that Conner was a knight and Emily was a knave could be true. Gabrielle, Eddie, and Exodus.

We thought they were both knaves because if Emily is a knave and she said they knights that would mean they are both knaves, In the end that means they are both lying. Rachel Catherine Emily

We think that Connor is a knight and Emily is a Knave because Connor is a knight then him saying that emily being knave must be true. Then Emily saying that her and connor being a knight is a lie making her a knave. Collin, John

We thought they were both knaves because Emily said that they were both knights when only a knave would say that because they wanted to be a knight. Conner said Emily was a knave and only a knave would say to portray he is a knight when he really isn't. Sarah Dobbs, Samantha Carter, and Julie Kuzniczci

We thought they both were knaves because ( pretty much the same as above) Emily said they were both knights when a knave would say that because they wanted to be a knight. Connor said Emily was a knave when only a knave would say that to show that he is a knight when he is not a knight. Anna F. Casey K.

We thought they both were at first but then we realized connor cannot lie and emily can coming to the conclusion connor is a knight and emily is a knave.Robby,Haley,Connor

I, Spencer Shinkle, think that they were both knaves because if Emily is a knave and she said they knights that would mean they are both knaves, In the end that means they are both lying.


 * =__//i think emily is a night and connor is a night ten him saying that emily is a night and must be true. then emily saying that her and connor is being a night. STUART MARSH.//__=